All-Time MLB Starting Pitcher Draft

What’s going on everybody, as you know we love to draft. So we have started a new draft series where we will do 5 round drafts and have Twitter decide the winners. This time we did an all-time MLB starting pitcher draft. Along with myself, we had FSS correspondents Dave, Brett, Timbo, & Blake participate in the draft. The tournament is constructed as a single elimination round robin, meaning if a team loses, they’re out. This time, the voting turned out to show two dominant teams. Team Maddux (your eventual winner) and Team Clemens. Those two teams had a battle in the Finals with Team Maddux winning with 50.5 % of the vote. Let’s take a look at the teams and the voting results.

Series Standings

Timbo2All-Time Starting Pitchers, All-Time MLB IF
TK2All-Time NFL Skills, Current NBA


SPRandy JohnsonRoger ClemensPedro MartinezGreg MadduxWalter Johnson
SPJustin VerlanderSandy KoufaxClayton KershawNolan RyanCy Young
SPBob GibsonTom SeaverChristy MathewsonSteve CarltonWarren Spahn
SPJohan SantanaRoy HalladayMax ScherzerTom GlavineLefty Grove
SPCurt SchillingJim PalmerBob FellerGrover AlexanderDon Sutton

Voting Results – Single Elimination Round Robin – Team Randy Johnson def. Team Walter Johnson

Voting Results – Single Elimination Round Robin – Team Clemens def Team Martinez

Voting Results – Single Elimination Round Robin – Team Maddux def Team Johnson

Finals Voting Results – Team Maddux def Team Clemens

Winner: Team Maddux (Timbo)

  • Greg Maddux
  • Nolan Ryan
  • Steve Carlton
  • Tom Glavine
  • Grover Alexander


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here